QuickBooks won’t let a single transaction post to both an accounts receivable account and an accounts payable account, and it rejects any entry that tries. The rule covers journal entries as well as other transaction types, which means moving a balance from AR to AP has to happen through a third account, usually called a clearing account.
Key Takeaways
- QuickBooks blocks any transaction that posts directly to both an accounts receivable and an accounts payable account.
- Common triggers include applying customer credits to vendor balances, intercompany transfers, reclassifying entries, and refunds tied to vendor overpayments.
- The workaround is a clearing account set up under Bank or Other Current Assets, sometimes called a wash or suspense account.
- Moving a balance from AR to AP takes two journal entries, first debiting the clearing account and crediting AR, then debiting AP and crediting clearing.
- After both entries post, the clearing account should show a zero balance, and the extra steps add time and raise the chance of errors.
Why QuickBooks Requires a Clearing Account
In properly maintained books, accounts receivable is kept separate from accounts payable. Accounts receivable records the amounts that customers owe to the business, and accounts payable records the amounts that the business owes to vendors. Accounts receivable is reported separately from accounts payable, and accounts receivable is not intended to be offset against accounts payable, so QuickBooks enforces the separation between accounts receivable and accounts payable at the point a transaction is entered.
The QuickBooks rule applies even when the same company is both a customer of the business and a vendor to the business. A company that is both a customer and a vendor is a more common situation than many business owners expect, and the customer-vendor situation is usually where the QuickBooks restriction is first encountered.
A customer credit cannot be applied against a vendor balance in QuickBooks. When a company owes the business on an invoice and the business owes the same company on a bill, the logical step is to net the invoice against the bill, although QuickBooks does not allow the customer credit to be applied to the vendor bill directly.
Intercompany transfers are subject to the same QuickBooks restriction, because a business with more than one entity often has one entity invoicing a second entity while the first entity also owes money to the second entity on a separate matter, and the intercompany amounts cannot be netted in QuickBooks without an intermediate account.
Reclassifications between accounts receivable and accounts payable are affected by the QuickBooks restriction as well, since an entry recorded in accounts receivable may turn out to belong in accounts payable, or an entry recorded in accounts payable may turn out to belong in accounts receivable, and correcting either entry requires the same clearing account workaround as any other movement between accounts receivable and accounts payable.
A refund arising from a vendor overpayment, where the vendor is also a customer, is affected in the same way, because QuickBooks does not allow the overpayment balance to be moved from accounts payable to accounts receivable in a single step.
The Clearing Account Workaround
A clearing account is an ordinary account that holds a balance for a short period while the balance is moved from one side of the books to the other side of the books. A clearing account is also called a wash account or a suspense account, and the terms clearing account, wash account and suspense account refer to the same type of account.
The clearing account is set up in QuickBooks under the Bank category or the Other Current Assets category. QuickBooks does not require any particular name for the clearing account, and “Clearing Account” and “Intercompany Clearing” are commonly used names.
Moving a balance out of accounts receivable requires two journal entries rather than one journal entry. In the journal entry that moves the balance out of accounts receivable, the clearing account is debited and accounts receivable is credited, and in the journal entry that moves the balance into accounts payable, accounts payable is debited and the clearing account is credited.
Once both journal entries have been posted, the clearing account should return to a zero balance. A remaining balance in the clearing account indicates either that one of the journal entries was not completed or that the two journal entries were posted for different amounts.
The Downsides of Using a Clearing Account
The clearing account workaround produces correct books, although the clearing account workaround also creates problems that a direct transaction between accounts receivable and accounts payable would not create.
Two journal entries have to be prepared, reviewed and posted where a single transaction would otherwise have been sufficient, and the cost of preparing, reviewing and posting two journal entries is incurred every time the situation arises.
The additional journal entry also increases the opportunity for error in the books, and the most common error is posting the first journal entry and failing to post the second journal entry, which leaves a balance stranded in the clearing account and leaves both accounts payable and accounts receivable misstated until the stranded balance is noticed.
The clearing account process also places a significant demand on the person who keeps the books. Business owners without accounting training generally find the clearing account process the most difficult, and business owners without accounting training are also the least likely to notice when the clearing account process has gone wrong.
Reconciliation of the clearing account is a further consideration at every close, because a clearing account should always carry a zero balance, so any balance in the clearing account has to be investigated, and the investigation adds a recurring task to every month-end close.
Why QuickBooks Should Address This Issue
Some accounting platforms handle transactions between accounts receivable and accounts payable without an intermediate account. Those accounting platforms keep accounts receivable and accounts payable separate in the underlying records while still allowing the transaction to be entered in the way that the transaction actually occurred.
A linking feature would resolve the issue within QuickBooks, since with a linking feature an accounts receivable transaction would be connected to an accounts payable transaction, and QuickBooks would create the offsetting entries automatically. An automated offset would also resolve the issue, with QuickBooks recognizing that a customer and a vendor are the same party and suggesting the appropriate netting entry.
A Different Approach: GlassJar Accounting Software
GlassJar handles the customer-who’s-also-a-vendor problem differently. One GlassJar contact can be a customer and a vendor at the same time, so what you owe and what you’re owed sit together on one record.
Accounts receivable and accounts payable still stay separate in the ledger, so your reports come out right, and you can see both sides of the relationship in one place. See what GlassJar can do for your books.

























